Toby: A Man

Boyish Babiak

TOBY: A MAN by Todd Babiak (HarperCollins), 330 pages, $22.99 cloth. Rating: NN

Redemption is a beautiful thing, but not when you can see it coming on page 50 of a 300-page novel.


That’s the basic trouble with Todd Babiak’s Toby: A Man. The satire lseems promising – all edgy, sometimes outrageous, while it tracks the downfall of Toby Ménard, an on-air TV personality whose specialty is men’s etiquette. And then it goes way soft.

After a harrowing day spent drinking at a men’s club, then rescuing his father from a flaming car, then heading to his girlfriend for warmth, Toby isn’t ready for his prime-time interview with the Conservative candidate in a federal by-election. He makes a ludicrous racist gaffe that leads to his being axed from the station.

In the narrow field of Quebec’s English-language television, that’s it for Toby’s career. Goodbye, condo and BMW. Hello, Mom and Dad’s basement. In the meantime, he has a one-night stand with a woman who suddenly dumps her toddler with him and disappears.

What could have been a caustic commentary on English-French relations in Montreal turns into a feel-good fairy tale. Toby’s silly, superficial TV gig could have been a vehicle for eviscerating a changing and fiercely competitive media landscape, but Babiak fails to follow through.

The female characters are all distressingly toxic, including Toby’s mother, Karen, which makes Toby’s life-altering decisions at the end seem positively demented.

Babiak handles the men with kid gloves – even Toby’s obnoxious TV mentor, Adam Demsky, is strangely endearing – so what starts out as a satire on status-obsessed men’s clubs turns into an exercise in male bonding.

The prose is breezy and lively enough. Too bad Toby: A Man’s themes are just as light.

Babiak launches his novel at the Dora Keogh on Tuesday (February 23). See Readings.

Leave your opinion for the editor...We read everything!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *