How To Build A Solid Sketch Troupe

Fast-rising ensemble Dame Judy Dench discuss their unusual name, coming up with material and the importance of delicious snacks


If you’ve been attending the Toronto Sketch Comedy Festival, which closes this weekend, you have a good idea of what makes a successful comedy troupe. There’s no magic formula, of course, but the best ones have some things in common. I’m using one of the most exciting ensembles, the five-person Dame Judy Dench, to see what’s essential. The stars of several sold-out Fringe revues, including last year’s Everything Else Is Sold Out, play one more show on Saturday (March 11) at the Theatre Centre. torontosketchfest.com.

Have a funny, or at least ­memorable, name

The women in the troupe – Claire Farmer, Jessica Greco and Shannon Lahaie – came up with the jokey name when they met in their Second City conservatory class and put on their first show as a trio. “We almost came up with Dame Maggie Smith,” says Greco. “Just because we liked the joke of ‘Welcome to the stage… Dame Maggie Smith… or Dame Judy Dench’ and then disappointing people when we came out.’ When they expanded to include fellow classmate Gavin Pounds and friend Chris Leveille, they kept the name. To this day, a few patrons look confused at the shows. And the group occasionally get requests on social media to sign petitions as Dench. But if you’ll notice, the first name of the Oscar-winning actor is spelled wrong. That’s intentional. Farmer is a lawyer. “Of course I thought of that,” she says.

Include members with different experiences

There’s nothing more boring than sketch members who all do the same shtick.

That’s not the case with DJD. Farmer is a litigation lawyer who was advised to take an improv class to improve her on-her-feet skills. Greco had been in film and TV for 20 years and wanted to be seen as funnier by the industry. ­Lahaie studied theatre but always longed to do comic scenes. Pounds studied broadcasting and improv and saw a Second City brochure at a job fair. Leveille, who has degrees in math and drama, had an intern job near the Second City training centre and always wondered what it would be like to improvise. He’s been doing improv and sketch ever since.

That range helps them keep things fresh, says Lahaie. “We have different ways of seeing the world, and different things we want to do with comedy.”

“We have five different voices, performance styles and backgrounds that work wonderfully together,” says Greco. “And when you put five very different ingredients into a pot, you’ll often get something a bit strange.”

Don’t be precious about your material

There’s no ego involved in writing and holding onto material, says Farmer. Someone who comes up with a premise doesn’t necessarily feel territorial about the final product after it’s been altered. And if a bit isn’t working, they’ll frankly say so and drop it or ­finesse it. “None of us is super-precious­,” she says. “Every director we’ve had has found it so strange when it comes to whittling down our material, because we’ll cut something before they do.”

According to Lahaie, the troupe’s motto is “funniest wins.” That said, if even one of the five finds a sketch ­offensive, it’s taken off. “That’ll mean people in the audience will, too,” says Greco.

Realize that even the silliest sketches need internal logic

DJD have had some absurd scenes – one features Farmer in a pizza costume, for instance, and Pounds frequently shows up without a shirt – but they’re grounded in logic.

“We always make sure things make sense in the world we’re building,” says Leveille. “‘Why would this character do this?’ The jokes always have to fit in the context.”

Lahaie agrees. “Are we saying something because it builds a scene up or just because it’s funny and we’re throwing it in?”

That applies to endings as well – the weakest link for most aspiring sketch troupes. Anyone can come up with a good premise, but knowing how to land it is an art form.

“Even if you had the funniest, smartest premise,” says Farmer, “if the sketch just peters out you lose everything that came before.”

Have fun

“This isn’t exactly glamorous,” says Greco. Besides the glory of getting applause, there’s paperwork, fundraising, publicity, applying to festivals. “We’re doing it because we enjoy the work, enjoy each other’s company and making people laugh. If any of that stops being true, then we probably won’t do it any more. If you’re not having fun, take up another hobby.”

“I hear knitting is really big now,” quips Farmer.

… and don’t forget snacks

This fact comes up continually. Tech people essentially volunteering their time will be happier with a box of Timbits, says Greco. And writing meetings, says Pounds, are potlucks where people bring everything from pies and chips to ketchup-flavoured Doritos.

“We basically bring diabetes to the table,” says Greco.

Leave your opinion for the editor...We read everything!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *