WINNER: The East’s GERRARD SPAGHETTI & PIZZA (1528 Danforth)
Okay, so it’s no longer on Gerrard and you’re not here for the Bolognese. But this well-loved 40-year-old trat bakes thin-crusted pies that rival Terroni and Libretto. Sadly, eat-in and pickup only.
WEST CONTENDER: PIZZA GIGI (189 Harbord)
Yes, these retro pies are almost too old-school, but at least you can get them delivered till 4 am.