Joel Edgerton's film about gay conversion therapy is moving, serious and could help save lives
BOY ERASED SPEC D: Joel Edgerton. 114 min. Sep 11, 9 pm, Princess of Wales Sep 12, 2:30 pm, Princess of Wales Sep 15, noon, Roy Thomson Hall. See listing. Rating: NNNN
Edgerton’s second feature is a moving, sober and occasionally rambling adaptation of Garrard Conley’s memoir of his harrowing time spent in a gay conversion therapy program.
The only child of an Arkansas Baptist preacher (Russell Crowe) and his dutiful wife (Nicole Kidman), Jared (Lucas Hedges) is sent to the ironically named Love In Action program run by the tightly wound Victor Sykes (Edgerton).
Under Sykes’s iron fist, gender roles are rigid (boys shouldn’t cross their legs), touching is forbidden and all washroom visits have to be supervised. Sykes believes same-sex attraction is a result of other aberrant things in one’s family tree – you know, like drugs, gambling and abortion.
Working on homework at night while staying with his mom at a nearby hotel, Jared flashes back to show us how he ended up here, and this choppy structure affects the film’s rhythms and initially keeps us at a remove from the characters.
But as Jared’s past catches up with his present, the film takes on a cumulative emotional weight, and Hedges’s performance – he’s emerging as one of his generation’s most versatile actors – starts to deepen. Jared doesn’t get to say much, but one scene in which he lashes out at a homoerotic bus shelter ad speaks volumes about his struggles.
Edgerton films the indoor indoctrination sequences with claustrophobic sterility, and he’s cast the roles creatively: director Xavier Dolan and YouTube personality Troye Sivan play contrasting inmates who’ve each found a way to survive (barely), while the tattooed musician Flea plays a particularly sadistic instructor. Crowe and Kidman both get their awards clip moments.
What’s most impressive about the film is its restraint. There are no villains. Everyone thinks they’re doing the right thing. And that, combined with the statistics about the number of states that still run such programs, is the tragedy.
Perhaps this film can change things – and help save lives.