While Pony Up!'s first EP for Dim Mak met with middling reviews, the disc's greatest asset was the way it corrupted the ladies' slumber-party girl-pop with a sassiness that found 'em cooing prettily about wanting to be Matthew Modine's blow job queens. Sadly, Make Love To The Judges With Your Eyes is lacking in the racy edge department. Keyboardist Laura Wills and guitarist Sarah Moundroukas share vocal and songwriting duties, but it's hard to tell which Pony's behind which tunes, since nearly every jangly track's based on the same themes: crushing out and/or breaking up. If the girls dug deeper than Dr. Seuss rhymes and "in your arms" imagery, MLTTJWYE might work as an Exile In Guyville-type concept piece; as it stands, Pony Up! sound more like Juliana Hatfield covering contemporary Liz Phair.