
Some Toronto-area residents are speaking out against landlords for allegedly discriminating against potential tenants based on their gender, and one lawyer is reminding the public that the practice is highly illegal.
The concerns are being raised on a Reddit post after a user posted a screenshot of a Facebook marketplace conversation between themselves and a rental lister which ended in the tenant being turned away due to being male.
The tenant, who was seeking an apartment alongside two of his friends, was asked by the lister if they were guys or girls. After answering the question, the lister then said the landlord wouldn’t accept the application due to “past experience.”
Despite mentioning that all potential tenants have strong credit scores, stable incomes, and references, the rental hunter was still turned away.
“Won’t work, sorry,” the lister said.
The post has garnered a lot of attention, with some users replying with similar experiences.
“I’ve seen dudes say they only want female tenants. I find it pretty weird tbh,” a user said.
“I had a landlord when I was in school in London. He refused to rent one of his houses out to all women because the drama was through the roof from such situations in the past,” another user said.
“I once rented in the GTA around 2018… The overwhelming number of listings that have sex, religious, food based (vegetarian) or cultural demands was crazy. So many half decent places in my price range I had to immediately cross out because I didn’t fit,” another user said.
DISCRIMINATING AGAINST TENANTS IS ILLEGAL, LAWYER SAYS
Canadian Human Rights lawyer Thuraya S. A. Lutfi tells Now Toronto that although it may be difficult to prove, discriminating against a tenant is very much illegal, and both landlords and tenants are protected under the Ontario Human Rights Code.
“The code protects individuals from discrimination in housing based on various grounds, like gender and other grounds as well, such as religion, race, ethnic origin, disability, to name a few,” she said.
However, Lutfi says that those grounds have to be engaged in order for the tenant to claim discrimination.
Incidents like this one are nothing new for lawyers like Lutfi who says she has worked with tenants in the past who felt like they were being discriminated against, oftentimes in more ways than one.
“We have had cases where tenants feel like they’ve been discriminated against… but more so on the grounds of race and family status. So, people that have, for example, larger families, are usually told, ‘No, we can’t give you this apartment or condo,’” she said.
If it is proven that a tenant has been discriminated against, Lutfi says the landlord can face a fine starting at $10,000 to as big as $100,000. Lutfi says higher amounts are reserved for more “severe cases.”
But she warns that there is a small window when filing complaints with the Human Rights Tribunal related to discrimination.
“There’s usually a year from when an incident occurs that individuals can file… So, usually sooner is better than later to kind of get to the Human Rights Tribunal if that is something that is being considered,” she said.
Lutfi emphasizes that everyone’s case is different, and the legal information may not apply to everyone.
