Advertisement

Culture Music

Toronto singer-songwriter Craig Stickland plays intimate “stories” show on Sunday

After 11 years in Los Angeles, the singer-songwriter is reconnecting with Toronto’s music scene, refining his approach to songwriting and finding creative freedom outside the pressures of making a living from music.

Toronto singer-songwriter Craig Stickland recording in a cozy living room studio with guitars, pedals, and a coffee mug on a round table.
After 11 years in Los Angeles, Toronto singer-songwriter Craig Stickland returned to the city in 2025 and is reconnecting with its music scene. (Courtesy: Karen Bliss)

What to know

  • After 11 years in Los Angeles, Toronto singer-songwriter Craig Stickland returned to the city in 2025 and is reconnecting with its music scene.
  • Stickland will perform Songs & Stories, an intimate solo acoustic show at The Bell & The Beacon this Sunday.
  • Best known for his work with We Are The Take and his solo career, Stickland has also toured internationally with Alessia Cara and earned a Juno nomination.
  • With a new approach to songwriting, Stickland is working on new material and hopes to write a song for each of his monthly Toronto shows over the next year.

Craig Stickland has been finding his way back into Toronto’s music scene since returning to the city in 2025, after 11 years in Los Angeles. This summer, he played a sold-out show at the Pilot, then another gig at the Piston, and earlier this month made a surprise appearance at Justin Nozuka’s show at the Opera House. 

This Sunday, he’ll perform Songs & Stories, an intimate solo acoustic show at The Bell & The Beacon, where he’ll talk about the inspiration or circumstances behind his songs.

Stickland’s career began in Toronto in 2007, as one half of the duo We Are The Take, formed with Erik Alcock, now a successful songwriter for other acts. When they disbanded, Stickland went on to pursue a solo career, releasing Leave Me To The Wild in 2016.  That year, he toured internationally as a guitarist in Alessia Cara’s band.

Music isn’t his only creative pursuit. Stickland also works as an actor, appearing in Amazon’s Cross, Peacock’s Twisted Metal, as well as in the film Scott Pilgrim vs the World.

His 2020 album Starlit Afternoon, on his then-manager’s label, 21 Entertainment, earned a nomination for Adult Contemporary Album of the Year at the 2021 Juno Awards. His most recent release is the 2023 EP Lost in the Rewind on MNRK.

Advertisement

Setting up shows monthly in Toronto, the plan is to have a new song ready for every gig he does over the next year, so that he’ll end up with a full album of show-tested songs. 

Ahead of Sunday’s performance, we spoke with Stickland about the upcoming gig, creative feedback, his new approach to songwriting, and his “duty” as a writer.

On Sunday, will you be sharing a story behind every song, or just select ones?

I’m still rehearsing, so I don’t know, but I think some songs will have shorter stories.

It’s been a while since I’ve done an acoustic show. When you have a band, there are more opportunities to create instrumental moments and have more dynamics, and it’s easier to free-flow from one song to the next. As I continue to write songs for my next album, I want to peel back the curtain on where these songs came from.

You mentioned in a social media post that you’ve been writing songs for 25 years, and that you used to accept the first draft as the final version. Now you’re spending more time editing, refining and rethinking your lyrics. You even shared the same song four times, each with different lyrics. What changed in your approach to songwriting?

Advertisement

My mentor Mike McCarty [formerly of EMI Music Publishing; now of Kilometre Music Group], who’s been A&R-ing my next project, is really constructive about what needs to be improved. He’ll tell stories about all these iconic artists through the years. Apparently, Bruce Springsteen rewrote “Born to Run” 99 times over the course of six months because he knew he had something, but wanted to ensure it was absolutely the best possible song it could be.

I think there are some songs where you recognize a certain greatness, whether that’s melodically, thematically, or because they’re coming from a place of deep honesty and emotion. You want to make sure you capture that in the best way possible.

Rick Rubin often talks about making things for yourself, and that people will gravitate towards them if they’re honest to you. I agree with that to a certain degree, but I also feel that music is an escape for people. It gives people a way of feeling something they might not be able to express on their own. So, if a song is written about regret and someone is experiencing regret, I feel like it’s my duty as a writer to encapsulate that feeling as precisely as possible for someone else.

McCarty signed you to EMI Music Publishing Canada two decades ago. It must mean a lot to have his continued support and feedback, particularly now that the company no longer exists.

McCarty mentioned something that I find interesting: if someone’s choosing to listen to your music in this day and age, they have access to every single artist who’s ever existed. They can choose to listen to you, or they can discover The Beatles for the first time, hypothetically.

I feel like if you’re trying to be a professional musician versus a hobbyist, the bar is high. Your music is up against every unbelievable artist who’s ever existed because it’s all so readily available.

Advertisement

That’s caused me to reflect and ensure that the music is as good as it possibly can be, especially because I’ve already had a very successful career, but it’s lived on the edge of something bigger and hasn’t quite turned over. McCarty has instilled in me the idea that the only thing standing in the way of reaching a large number of people is the quality of the song.

The expectations of being a musician have changed considerably. There’s so much more required of artists now beyond songwriting and performing. How do feel about all that other stuff?

I actually struggle to put myself out there. I don’t enjoy the process of social media. I feel like it’s a laborious thing to do. There are other people who’ve become far more successful than I have without putting in as many reps. They’re just more willing to be like, “Look at me, I’m fucking amazing,” and be so confident about that, that it just works, especially in a front-facing career like this.

You’ve toured the world with Alessia Cara. One of your albums was nominated for a Juno. What is success to you?

There have definitely been a lot of periods in my life when I’ve felt like giving up or felt like I would never make it. Or that I had made it, but didn’t enjoy what that looked like, or it wasn’t what I expected. Signing a record deal, touring the world, getting nominated for a Juno and having millions of streams still didn’t quite feel like what I thought it would.

I think that’s mostly from a financial perspective, if I’m honest. It’s very difficult to make money as a musician. Success is very intangible. You can be quote-unquote successful but still be broke.

Advertisement

I’ve been lucky lately to be working as an actor and a model as well. That’s allowed me to find the passion for writing songs again, as opposed to having it be something that needs to generate an income, if that makes sense. I’m just trying to find the passion for writing from a place of self-expression, rather than writing with an end goal in mind.

Advertisement

Exclusive content and events straight to your inbox

Subscribe to our Newsletter

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

By signing up, I agree to receive emails from Now Toronto and to the Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions.

Recently Posted