
What to know
- Legendary Canadian power-pop band Sloan returned to the Concert Hall on Nov. 20 for night one of two sold-out shows celebrating 30 years of their third album, One Chord to Another.
- The band last played at the Concert Hall in 2024 for their debut album’s anniversary.
- Before stepping on stage, Sloan showcased a six-minute compilation video featuring clips, mostly from their MuchMusic days.
- The band also played through for the first time, Recorded Live at a Sloan Party!
Sloan, the beloved power-pop band that should be in the Canadian Music Hall of Fame, celebrated the 30th anniversary of their career-defining third album, One Chord to Another, with the first of two sold-out shows at the iconic Concert Hall in Toronto.
The Halifax-formed band, which helped put the city on the musical map as the “Seattle of the North” in the fertile ’90s, played the same venue in 2024 for the anniversary of their debut album, Smeared, and Peppermint EP. And from the video montage that kicked off the show, we learned they played it in the ’90s, too.
One Chord to Another is Sloan’s best-selling album, with sales of more than 80,000 copies. Not bad for an album recorded in just two weeks for a reported $10,000. It also won the band its first Juno Award for Alternative Album of the Year.
While their Instagram page advised us that Sloan would be on at 8 p.m. “to arrive early not to miss a chord,” of course, they went on 20 minutes later, as some people started chanting “Slow-own.”
The stage featured a huge backdrop of the blue One Chord to Another cover, shot by Catherine Stockhausen.
Before the band came out, the audience was treated to a fun six-minute video montage featuring quick-cut retro clips, mainly from the MuchMusic days, with VJs including Mike Campbell and Sook-Yin Lee.
Interviews touched on the breakup that didn’t last, Murphy’s revelation that his phobia is “I don’t like feet” and his belief that sports sandals are “the worst thing to be ever invented,” as well as the band’s “reputation for being nerds.” It also included a clip of them talking about playing the Concert Hall in Toronto for the first time in 1996.
Then they came out onstage: core members guitarist Chris Murphy, bassist Jay Ferguson, guitarist Patrick Pentland and drummer Andrew Scott, all of whom uniquely handle lead vocals, along with longtime keyboardist Gregory Macdonald, who joined in 2006 (so it’s his anniversary, too!).
Playing the album in sequence, they opened with the enduring “The Good in Everyone,” followed by “Nothing Left to Make Me Want to Stay” and “Autobiography,” with little between-song talk, except for a “Thanks so much, you guys” from Murphy. Many of the songs in the live setting were a lot heavier than their more pop-oriented recorded versions.
They continued with “Junior Panthers,” “G Turns to D,” “A Side Wins” and “Everything You’ve Done Wrong” (with trumpets), followed by “Anyone Who’s Anyone,” “The Lines You Amend,” “Take the Bench” (with trumpets), “Can’t Face Up” and “400 Metres.”
Murphy then gave the peace sign with both hands, pointed to his wrist and mouthed, “We’ll be back.”
After a 20-minute intermission, Sloan returned to play Recorded Live at a Sloan Party! live for the first time ever. The rare album was a bonus release accompanying One Chord to Another in the United States and Japan. They later included it in the 20th-anniversary set for One Chord to Another.
“When we put out One Chord to Another 30 years ago, 30 years,” Murphy emphasised, “No skips. Pretty good record.”
“The record came out in Canada in ’96, and then we got a short-lived record deal with a label called The Enclave. And when we put out that record with them, they wanted some kind of value add. And they were like, ‘Do a live record or something.’”
“Then we happened upon this idea — I think it was Jay’s idea — to sort of ape the Beach Boys’ Live at a Beach Boys Party record.
“The record features ‘Barbara Ann,’ which will not be played this evening. But we’re going to do our best to struggle through the Live at a Sloan Party record because it’s never been played before. The party was a fake. So now this is the first time we’re ever actually going to play this party record live.”
“If this is your first Sloan show, maybe I’m sorry,” he said to laughter, “but if it’s your 40th, you’re welcome.”
To kick it off, they brought out former Jale singer and fellow Haligonian Jennifer Pierce for “I Can Feel It,” after which Murphy told the audience that she has a new album out, Rhymes with Girl (under Jenny & the Tide), available at their merch booth. “Go get it.”
They then launched into the whole party record, mainly in order, except for a curious switcheroo of Roxy Music’s “Over You” and The Turtles’ “Glitter and Gold.” For the latter, which Scott sang, his wife, Fiona Highet, came out to join him on vocals at the front of the stage.
The set continued — the live album is mostly covers — including Matthew Grimson’s “Stood Up,” Canned Heat’s “On the Road Again,” Stereolab’s “Transona Five” and April Wine’s “I Wouldn’t Want to Lose Your Love.”
They then moved into the B-side portion of the night, playing Sloan’s “Stood Up” and “Same Old Flame,” before capping the evening with Smeared tracks “500 Up,” “Take It In” and the fan favourite “Underwhelmed.”
After 30 years, One Chord to Another still sounds fresh. It could be put out now and not sound even remotely dated. The Concert Hall show reminded us just how well the songs have held up, and why Sloan remain pop treasures.
