Advertisement

Culture Music

Should artists ban phones at concerts? A music writer gives her take

Phoebe Bridgers is the latest musician to ban phones at her concerts. Should this be more commonplace? A music writer gives her reasoning.

Crowd at a concert capturing the moment with a phone screen held up among the cheering audience.
Jack White, Bob Dylan, and Harry Styles have already banned phones at their shows. (Courtesy: Canva)

Should artists ban cell phones and other electronic devices at concerts?

In recent years, artists like Jack White, Bob Dylan, and Harry Styles have all enforced phone-free policies at their shows, forcing concertgoers to lock their phones, airpods, smart watches, and other devices in Yondr pouches. Fans who attempt to access the locked-up devices can cause undesired consequences like accidentally breaking their phone. 

Just this year, popular indie musician Phoebe Bridgers also announced that she would be banning phones and other recording devices at The Lost Tour. Fans who wanted a souvenir to remember Bridgers’ performance started bringing sketchpads and notebooks to their respective tour dates. 

Allie Gregory, a music writer and music industry professional, says artists want to have control over their brand and/or image. She says promoters even deny requests from reviewers and photographers.

“It’s now commonplace for promoters to deny reviewers and photographer requests at venues, or not approve photos even after allowing photographers to shoot,” Gregory explains. 

Advertisement

“Unless they outright ban phones too, artist management can’t maintain 100% control over their image.”

Although Gregory says she understands the sentiment of “wanting fans to be in the moment,” she suspects that’s often not the real reason artists ban phones. 

Except in the case of Jack White, she says, who has a longstanding preference for analog recording methods.

Paternalistic to ban phones

While it’s true that concert etiquette has gone down the drain over the last several years (blame the COVID-19 pandemic), Gregory says banning phones feels both dangerous and paternalistic.

“People who film the entire time are only ruining their own concert experience, not mine. I see the act of constantly filming as just another kind of bad concert etiquette,” she shrugs

Advertisement

“I rarely film, and when I do, it’s for a maximum of 15 seconds. I work in the industry and sometimes am required to film for my job.”

If artists don’t want their concerts to be filmed, Gregory says it’s up to them to cultivate a fanbase that “will agree not to film when asked.” 

Furthermore, she points to concerts where artists have asked fans to not film, or keep certain songs a secret, and says the request has been obeyed happily. 

“There’s been lots of talk since the pandemic about concert etiquette and how many young people lost formative years in which they would have learned how to behave at shows — it’s now up to experienced concertgoers to pass on this knowledge.”

Advertisement

Exclusive content and events straight to your inbox

Subscribe to our Newsletter

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

By signing up, I agree to receive emails from Now Toronto and to the Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions.

Recently Posted