Toronto real estate is sitting on a high-risk bubble: report

A Swiss investment bank ranks Toronto as third most at-risk for a bubble of all major cities in the world


Toronto real estate prices are so inflated that a Swiss investment bank is warning the city is sitting on a high-risk bubble.

Toronto ranks as the third most over-priced major city in the world, according to the UBS Global Real Estate Bubble Index.

Fair value would score -0.5 to 0.5 on UBS’s bubble index. Over-valued scores between 0.5 and 1.5. The city, where the average house price is $1,012,506, has a 1.96 rating. That is nearly four times as high as New York, which UBS calls over-valued at 0.56.

Among the most at-risk cities in the world, Toronto falls just behind Munich and Frankfurt. They score 2.35 and 2.26, respectively. And Toronto is at a greater risk for a “sharp correction” than Hong Kong (1.79) and Paris (1.68).

The only other Canadian city on the UBS index is Vancouver. Like Toronto, the west coast city was designated an at-risk bubble in 2018 with a 1.92 score. But Vancouver prices are milder now. In 2020, Vancouver is overvalued at 1.37, according to UBS. It’s still has a higher score than fellow “over-valued” cities like London, Tokyo, Los Angeles and San Francisco.

Dubai, Singapore, Milan and Madrid are among the cities the UBS index deems fair-valued.

Toronto real estate decline?

The report from UBS is the most recent warning that Toronto real estate prices could see a sharp decline.

The Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation’s spring outlook suggested that the average Toronto house price could bottom out at $739,000 in 2021. A recent report from Moody’s made a more conservative prediction that Toronto home prices could fall nine per cent next year.

These predictions repeatedly warn that the COVID-19 impact on employment and immigration will make home prices a little more humble.

The Canadian government and banks are delaying the COVID-19 impact with low mortgage rates, deferrals and financial assistance via CERB and other programs. But the UBS report argues that a decline in the rental market and the rapid inflation of pricing from the previous dozen years are reasons to expect a correction. The rising Canadian dollar will also disincentivize foreign investment.

But the hot Toronto real estate market repeatedly shrug off such sky is falling concerns.

Average house prices in Toronto broke ceilings in June, July and then August. We do not yet have data for September.

@justsayrad

Comments (3)

  • Robert Vinton October 4, 2020 12:12 AM

    Nobody remembers, or even knows, that Toronto home prices peaked in December 1989. In the following five years prices fell 30% to 35%. Anybody who bought in 1989 got badly hurt by 1994.
    This time Toronto prices are totally ridiculous. Anybody who pays $1 million for an ordinary home is nuts. I foresee a drop in prices far greater than what the ‘experts’ quote in this article – more like a 50% decline. Over the next few years the market will collapse. Lots of people & mortgage lenders are going to be financially devastated.

    • Ellie October 5, 2020 02:14 PM

      Reply to I remember that too and agree with you on all points. Before that, in the seventies, interest rates were so high (I recall 21% at one point) people with mortgages did lose their houses. Too many people today want to pretend none of that ever happened.

  • Marvin W Schlichting October 4, 2020 08:29 AM

    Re Toronto real-estate being over priced and over valued. Much as i like living in this city, it still lags way behind the cities its compared to as a world class city. Vancouver is even worse in this regard, but there its setting makes up for that. Even though it’s setting js obscured in cloud for months every year. It smells like a gathering of greed at work. Realtors and sellers alike. How sad.

Leave your opinion for the editor...We read everything!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *